FREQUENCY OF FOUR-ROOTED MOLARS IN 1,775 EXTRACTED UPPER MOLAR TEETH: A BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATION OF THIS CHALLENGING CLINICAL ANOMALY
Ikechukwu U. Madukwe
Department of Oral Surgery and Pathology School of Dentistry, College of Medical Sciences
University of Benin, Benin City, Nigeria
Background: Tooth development starts after the rupture of the buccopharyngeal membrane, establishing communication with the primitive digestive tract. Tooth development undergoes descriptive stages of initiation, bud, cap, bell and apposition. Root formation begins after crown formation by the Hertwig’s epithelial root sheath.
Methodology: The study material was the extracted 1,775 upper molar teeth. Each tooth was examined for the occurrence of four roots, using the clinical index for upper molar; possession of three roots; an extra root is an anomaly. The normal positions of the roots are two buccally and one palatal root.
Result: Out of a total of 1,775 upper molar teeth examined 8 (0.451%) were four-rooted. This makes a frequency of 0.451%.
Conclusion: We conclude that endodontist should have a pre-knowledge of anatomic variation in root canals, especially an awareness and understanding of the possible presence of an additional root and unusual root canal morphology. This is essential in determining the successful outcome of endodontic treatment.
Keyword: Four-rooted, molars, Biological, anomaly.
Tooth development starts after the rupture of the buccopharyngeal membrane, establishing communication with the primitive digestive tract. The surface oral ectoderm which has an underlying neural or ectomedenchyme cells are instructed by these cells to start tooth development,[2,3] this is through signaling networks mediating the epithelial-mesanchymal interactions. This affects tooth morphogenesis and patterning mammalian tooth development and it is largely dependent on sequential and reciprocal epithelial – mesenchymal interactions. These processes involve a series of inductive and permissive interactions that results in the determination, differentiation, and organization of odontogenic tissues. Tooth development undergoes descriptive stages of initiation, bud, cap, bell and apposition. After the crown formation is nearly complete, tooth root begins to develop with the guidance of the double layer of the epithelial sheath, called the Hertwig’s epithelial root sheath, which is formed from the outer and inner enamel apithelium at the neck ring of the crown and grows in the apical direction determining the root length, while the growth and fusion of the horizontal diaphragm determine the number of root. Four-rooted upper molars are not uncommon. Peikoff et al revealed a frequency of (1.4%), and Libfield and Roststein’s a frequency of (0.4%). Even maxillary second molars with six been reported by Branlio et al.10clinical endodontic practices are some times challenged by the presence of a fourth root in the upper molar region. These archived teeth therefore offers opportunity of determining its frequencies. This is a retrospective study of teeth collected over 10 years period from Department of Oral Surgery and Pathology, College of Medical Sciences, University of Benin.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study material was the extracted 1,775 upper molar teeth (Fig. I), stored into 10% formative bottle in line with Centre for Disease Control and Prevention guidelines for infection control of extracted teeth used for research and teaching.[11,12] Each tooth was examined for the occurrence of four-roots. The clinical index for upper molar was possession of three roots, an extra root is an anomaly. The normal positions of the roots are two buccally (musio-buccal and disto-buccal) and one palatal root. Individual upper root, identification was not of prime consideration as it bears no direct specific relevance to overall clinical treatment outcome.
Out of a total of 1,775 (100%) upper molar teeth examined, 8 (0.451%) were four-rooted (Fig. II). This makes a frequency of 0.451%.
Variation in root or root canal morphology, especially in multi-rooted, is challenging for diagnosis and successful endodontic therapy. The knowledge of common anatomic characteristics and their possible variation is fundamental. Uncommon variation may lead to failure of endodontic treatment, like the presence of extra-root. This unforeseen if unidentified will lead to patient complaint of persistent post medicament pain. The possibility of an extra canal or root has to be borne in mind, especially aberrant anatomical situation. Our finding revealed 0.451% frequency of four-rooted upper molar, which is in tandem with Libfield and Roststein result. A successful endodontic treatment depends on thorough cleaning, shaping and obturation of the canal system. The main reasons for endodontic failure are apical presence of microorganisms caused by incomplete instrumentation, inadequate cleaning, insufficient canal obturation and the presence of untreated canals. An undetected canal will remain untreated and will lead to failure of root canal therapy.[17-19] We conclude that edodontist should have a pre-knowledge of anatomic variation in root canals, especially an awareness and understanding of the possible presence of an additional root and unusual root canal morphology. This is essential in determining the successful outcome of endodontic treatment.
- Blackburn ST. Maternal, Fetal, and neonatal physiology: A clinical perspective, 2007, pp. 81-83.
- Rudy C, Melfi, Keith E. Allay. Permar’s oral embryology and microscopic anatomy. A text book for student, 2000, pp. 26-29.
- Watanebe K, Sasaki F, Takahama H: The ultra stomatum of oral buccopharyngeal membrane formation and rupture in the anuran embryo. The anatomical record, Jan 2005; 210(3): 513-524.
- Mlletich I, Sharpe PT. Normal and abnormal dental development. Human Mol. Gen. 2003 12 (Suppl. 1) R69-R73.
- Zhang YD, Chen Z, Song YQ, Liu C, Chen YP. Making a tooth: Growth factors, transcription factors, and stem cells. Cell Research. 2005 15, 301-316.
- Ten Cate’s oral histology, Nanci Els evier 2013, pages 70-94.
- Huang XF, Chai Y. molecular Regulatory mechanism of tooth root development. Int. J. Oral Sci. 2012, 4, 177-181.
- Peikoff MD, Christie WH, Fogel HM. The maxillary second molar: Variations in the number of roots and canals. Int. Endod. J. 1996; Nov. 29 (6): 365-9.
- Libfield H. Rotstein I. Incience of four rooted maxillary second molars: Literature review and radiographic survey of 1,200 teeth. J. Endod. 1989; 15: 129-131.
- Branlio PI, Cleonice ST, Ricardo GS, Luiz PV, Manoel DN. Treatment of a second maxillary moalr with six canals. Aut. Endod. J. 2007; 33: 42-45.
- Kumar M, Sequeira PS, Peters S, Bhat GK. Sterilization of extracted human teeth for educational use. Ind. J. Mad. Micro. 2005; 23 (4):256-8.
- Lee JJ, Nettey-Marbell A, Cook A. Jr., Pimeta LA, Leonard R, Ritter AV. Using extracted teeth for research: the effect of storage medium and sterilization on dentin bond strengths. J. Amer. Assoc. 2007 Dec. 138 (12): 1599-603.
- Jafazade H. Endodontic treatment of bilaterally occurring three-rooted maxillary premolars: A case report. Newzeal. Dent. J. June 2007; 103-104(2); 2:37-38.
14. Gakis P. Farmakins ER. Endodontic considerations on the variations of the anatomy of the Mandibular premolar 2013; 3(1) 10-16.
15. Mittal S, Kumar T, Mittlal S, Sharma J. Mandibular premolars with aberrant Canal morphology: An endodontic challenges. J. Cons. Dent. 2014 Sept. – Octo. 17(5): 491-494.
16. Raju RVSC, Chandrasekhar V, Singh CV, Pasari S. Maxillary molar with two palatal roots: Two case reports. J. Conserv. Dent. 2010 Jan-Mar; 13(1): 58-61.
17. Siqueria JF Jr., Rocas: Clinical implications and microbiology of bacterial persistence after treatment procedures. J. Endod. 2008; 34: 1291 – 301.
18. Dow PR, Ingle JI: Isotope determination of root-canal failure. Oral Surg. Oral Med. Oral Path. Oral Radiol. Endod. 1955; 8: 1100-1104.
19. Sujatha I, Nadig PL, Chandra SM, Favook AZ: Radix distolingualis: A second palatal root in a maxillary molar: A case report. Endodontology 2003, 25 (2): 102-105.